• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

MAYDAY

  • Culture
  • Interviews
  • Reviews
  • Nonfiction
    • Contests
  • Translation
  • Fiction
  • Poetry
  • About
    • Submit
      • Contests
      • Contest Winners
      • MAYDAY:Black
    • Open Positions
    • Masthead
    • Contributors

MICHAEL ROBBINS’S RESPONSE TO “SOME DARKER BOUQUETS”

April 1, 2009 Contributed By: Michael Robbins

I prize wit and brio in reviews—style—more than confirmation of my own aesthetic judgments. Manny Farber on John Wayne: “the termite actor focusing only on a tiny present area, nibbling at it with engaging professionalism and a hipster sense of how to sit in a chair leaned against the wall.” It is more difficult to praise something well, as Farber does here, than to tear something down, so demolition must be surgically inventive, as in Robert Christgau’s takedown of Mary Chapin Carpenter: “Why do I believe this Nashville liberal showers three times a day and doesn’t think sex is the right place to get your face wet?” William Logan has the skill and precision of a skeet shooter; Dale Peck is just OK at Whack-a-Mole.

That said, I don’t quite recognize the state of contemporary poetry criticism in Jason Guriel’s analysis. Franz Wright’s unbalanced menacing of Logan notwithstanding, poetry reviewing is a fairly blithe business. The New York Times published an article some years ago about the dangers facing hip-hop reviewers, whose targets do not always confine their indignation to letters to the editor. I’m not suggesting that existential peril is what is missing from poetry reviewing (although I might feel a certain frisson if more handgun-wielding poets began stalking reviewers who had savaged their genre-busting verse ballets in the pages of Rain Taxi). But style will only get you so far unless it is in the service of the determination of what is of value in poetry. Allen Grossman admits to being uncertain what poetry “can now mean in the context of the actual human task. What obligations ‘poetry’ requires. What benefit to the human world the obligation, privilege, or competence named ‘poetry’—the vocation to ‘poetic work’—implies or promises. Above all, what knowledge it contributes.” No one else knows either. In On Criticism, whose back cover I read in its entirety while standing in line at the bookstore, Noel Carroll cites a poll of art critics in which 75 percent reported that rendering judgments on artworks was the least important part of their job. I recently conducted my own unscientific poll by asking avatars of reviewers in my head, and the numbers work out about the same for poetry critics. It may be that in order to render judgment, one must have a sense of what poetry “can now mean in the context of the actual human task.”

But what is the actual human task? That is not a question that hip-hop, for instance—the most vibrant art form of the last three decades—has much trouble formulating. It is a music that speaks directly to and on behalf of lived contradictions. Jazz used to do this. “Good reviews of late Coltrane,” Ben Ratliff writes, “often weren’t just good reviews. They were across-the-board endorsements, fighting-words defenses, reflections of a profound change of life that was caused directly by Coltrane’s music.” Critics had a sense that jazz provided a tangible “benefit to the human world.” This didn’t always lead to great criticism (Ratliff quotes Frank Kofsky: “The music is in effect telling us about a future existence in which love and cooperation have replaced strife and oppression”), but it ensured an environment in which great criticism was possible.

I don’t know if poetry exists in such an environment today (I doubt jazz does, anymore, either). None of which is to deny the potential charms of Kent’s proposal (although it may explain my sense that it would be hard to find reviewers other than Kent willing to forego their byline), only to say that I am not convinced that changes in reviewing protocols would do more than lessen the severity of a few symptoms of a larger condition. And I know that my appeal to popular music will strike some as willfully irrelevant to a discussion of poetry criticism (as my consistent blurring of “reviewing” and “criticism” will strike some as question-begging). But it may be that the necessary deflation of vatic possibility that has accompanied post-romantic poetic thinking has also diminished our capacity for a vital faith—faith in what Oppen called “the small nouns / Crying faith / In this in which.” We are too smart to believe that poetry might tell us about a future existence. I don’t necessarily deplore this development. It is, as Usher says, what it is.

 

Read more responses here.

Return to table of contents for Issue 1 Spring 2009

Filed Under: Nonfiction Posted On: April 1, 2009

Further Reading

Unspoken in an Undated Photograph
by Lee Colin Thomas

Of these five boys in black and white one stands alongside the joke the others make of their cable-knit sweaters and thigh-cut shorts. Some October Saturday, off to scrimmage, they smirk and pose for this photo. Later captioned Sophomore Antics in the campus paper. Did he, the one, find a strange education in his boarding-school […]

Reunion
by Susan Lynn Solomon

I flew to Florida because Laura, my cousin, my best and only friend, insisted I had to. The family was gathering for her mother’s funeral. I didn’t want to go—trembled when I thought of the ghosts waiting at the cemetery. Ghosts of my past were better left interred. But Laura dug her heels into my […]

Three Prose Poems
by Dag T. Straumsvåg, translated from the Norwegian by Robert Hedin

Today the warden has come to visit. He hands me a napkin with a color print of “The Storming of the Bastille” on one side, an escape plan on the other.

Primary Sidebar

Recently Published

  • Year-End Wrap-Up: The MAYDAY Editors’ Books of the Year, 2022
  • Warrior
    by Lane Falcon
  • Inside the Kaleidoscope
    by Jane O. Wayne
  • Two Poems by Luis Alberto de Cuenca
    translated from the Spanish by Gustavo Pérez Firmat
  • I Hope Your Birthday Is So Beautiful, It Hurts to Look at It
    by Josette Akresh-Gonzales

Trending

  • Eight Contemporary Female Irish Artists to Fall In Love With Immediately
    by Aya Kusch
  • Warrior
    by Lane Falcon
  • Sellouts 1970: Love Story: The Year a Screenplay-Turned-Novel Almost Broke the National Book Award
    by Kirk Sever
  • George Saunders on A Swim in a Pond in the Rain
    by Brianna Di Monda
  • I Hope Your Birthday Is So Beautiful, It Hurts to Look at It
    by Josette Akresh-Gonzales
  • Year-End Wrap-Up: The MAYDAY Editors’ Books of the Year, 2022
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Footer

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Business


Reprint Rights
Privacy Policy
Archive

Engage


Open Positions
Donate
Contact Us

Copyright © 2023 · New American Press

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.